The Church Is Gaslighting Men (And This Viral Story Proves It)
- rob6022
- Apr 13
- 3 min read
Intro
A recent viral story involving Trevor Sheatz has sparked a heated debate online.
But the real issue isn’t the man or his marriage.
It’s what the reaction to that story reveals.
Because what we’re witnessing right now is something much bigger: a pattern of gaslighting men inside the modern church.
The Double Standard No One Wants to Admit
If you look at the modern church landscape, one thing becomes very clear.
There is no shortage of accountability for men.
Sermons on sexual purity. Programs for pornography addiction. Accountability groups. Books, courses, and entire ministries built around correcting male behavior.
And to be fair, when men are in sin, they should be corrected.
But where is that same energy for women?
Because the same data often used to highlight men’s struggles also shows that a significant percentage of women are dealing with the same issues.
Yet the tone is completely different.
Less correction. Less accountability. Less direct confrontation.
Instead, we’ve created a culture where women are often protected, while men are constantly corrected.
That’s not biblical.
That’s cultural.
The Weaponization of Grace
The core issue isn’t forgiveness.
It’s how forgiveness is being used.
When a man says:
“I believe in forgiveness… but I don’t want to marry a woman with a promiscuous past.”
He’s not denying the gospel.
He’s exercising discernment.
But in today’s church, that distinction is being erased.
Men are told:
“You’re a Pharisee.” “You don’t understand grace.” “You’re being judgmental.”
This is where the gaslighting happens.
Because forgiveness is being weaponized to pressure men into ignoring reality.
And that’s not what grace was ever meant to do.
Consequences Still Exist
Grace saves your soul.
It does not erase consequences.
It does not remove patterns.
And it does not eliminate the need for wisdom in decision-making.
We understand this in every other area of life.
You wouldn’t go into business with someone who has a long track record of financial irresponsibility.
You wouldn’t ignore patterns of behavior when making serious decisions.
But when it comes to marriage, men are told to do exactly that.
That inconsistency is what’s driving so many men to frustration.
Why Men Are Speaking Up
The backlash you’re seeing right now isn’t random.
Men are not speaking up because they hate women.
They’re not speaking up because they reject redemption.
They’re speaking up because they recognize the double standard.
They see the contradiction.
And they’re tired of being told to ignore it.
The Bigger Problem
This isn’t about one viral story.
It’s about what happens when a system consistently rewards the wrong behaviors and penalizes the right ones.
When faithfulness is ignored… and failure is platformed.
When discernment is shamed… and naivety is celebrated.
When grace is used not to restore people… but to pressure others into bad decisions.
That system will eventually collapse.
And that’s exactly what we’re starting to see.
The Way Forward
If the church wants to bring men back, something has to change.
It has to:
Stop gaslighting men. Stop shaming them for having standards. Stop protecting women from accountability. And start telling the truth again.
Because until that happens, men will continue to walk away.
And the ones who stay?
They won’t stay silent.
Conclusion
The Trevor Sheatz situation didn’t create this issue.
It exposed it.
And whether people want to admit it or not, the conversation is already happening.
The only question now is whether the church is willing to face it honestly.
Men, discovering biblical marriage is one thing. Living it is another. Join Man of Options, a thriving Skool community of Christian men learning how to pursue and build biblical marriages in the real world. Free 7-day trial 👉 manofoptions.com
And if you'd like some 1-on-1 help, apply to work with me Here.
Comments